Pointed out to me in email, this terrific review (sadly behind a paywall) in TLS ("Too spirited for the spooks," Jon Barnes, 7 January 2005) of The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes, edited by the frankly "
affirmational" fan Leslie S. Klinger, who plays "the parlour game of Sherlockian scholarship":
Initiated in 1911 by a Catholic priest who intended
(
Read more... )